Anonymous Op-Ed Critiques ‘Good Ones’ Label, Citing Societal Division
A Portland resident submitted an anonymous "I, Anonymous" piece to the Portland Mercury reflecting on the phrase "one of the good ones." The author, a white man, discusses how this phrase, often historically used by white people towards Black men,…
Portland, OR, August 2, 2026 —
An anonymous opinion piece published in the Portland Mercury examines the phrase “one of the good ones,” arguing that such labels, regardless of intent, foster societal division and “othering.” The author, who identifies as a white man, reflected on his personal experience with the phrase, noting its historical context and its perceived impact.
The “I, Anonymous” submission details how the author felt receiving the label “one of the good ones.” He draws a parallel to the phrase’s historical usage by white individuals towards Black men, suggesting that even when applied to himself, it felt like a backhanded compliment.
The central argument presented in the piece is that classifying individuals as “good ones” contributes to a broader societal issue of division. According to the author, such distinctions, even when intended positively, reinforce an “othering” dynamic rather than promoting genuine acceptance and inclusion. The piece suggests that these labels create arbitrary categories that hinder authentic connection and understanding between groups.
The author’s reflection aims to shed light on the subtle ways language can perpetuate social stratifications. By questioning the underlying implications of seemingly innocuous praise, the anonymous writer encourages a deeper consideration of the impact of such labels on fostering a more equitable and unified society. The piece does not provide specific instances beyond the author’s personal reflection on receiving the label.
Story summarized from the original created by Anonymous on www.portlandmercury.com, see more information here.
